Substack
Each of these is a real decision Substack is working through, written so you can make the call yourself — incomplete information, someone who pushes back, no answer key.
Substack is a direct-to-audience publishing and monetization platform serving independent writers, journalists, podcasters, video creators, and media organizations. It provides integrated tools for creating, distributing, and monetizing newsletters, podcasts, video, and community content, with a focus on subscriber relationships and recurring revenue. Creators earn through paid subscriptions, and a Sponsorships team is building another way for creators to earn alongside them. The platform has over 5 million paid subscriptions to writers, podcasters, and video-makers. The UK is Substack's second largest market, with a fast growing network of publishers and creators spanning culture, food, history, gardening, current affairs, sports, and more. Substack integrates with payment processors and manages the flow of hundreds of millions of dollars in subscription revenue. Its engineering teams work with TypeScript, especially Node/Express and React, and Postgres, and its cloud infrastructure is hosted on AWS.
Your first one is free. No card.
15 live right now.
The rest
Commit paid-post access before the buyer moves seven figures
A seven-figure buyer needs four publishers to open paid posts, while publishers fear confusing paying readers. You have to weigh a guaranteed campaign audience against terms that preserve the value of paid subscriptions.
Reshape the proposal while the agency holds its budget
A $750,000 agency proposal is paused because two publishers declined the same brief. You must weigh buyer certainty against the publisher control that makes the campaign credible.
Trace payment failures without letting AI decide the fix
Paid subscribers can hold a successful payment while their access remains unclear. You must weigh faster evidence assembly against the engineer review needed before any production change.
Open publishing to contributors without sharing the owner account
Editors are sharing logins or holding posts until the account owner is available. You must weigh faster editorial publishing against clear account boundaries and byline attribution.
Choose a reversible limit over an irreversible fix before the campaign
Readers are reaching the wrong side of a paid-post paywall while publishers field questions about access. You must weigh a reversible access restriction against an irreversible entitlement correction under campaign pressure.
Prevent duplicate sends when segments change near delivery
Readers are receiving the same automation email twice within minutes. You must protect delivery reliability without suppressing a valid message.
Choose the next campaign test without slowing the learning loop
Strategists are reaching different conclusions from the same campaign results, delaying the next test. You must weigh faster recommendations against keeping message and spend decisions with the strategist.
Choose a channel and message that earn 120 publisher signups
Lean publishers are weighing a revenue share against flat monthly costs and more operational control. You have to choose a message and paid channel that earn qualified signups without promising a story the onboarding cannot support.
Choose one signal while creator ads split attribution
The next creator-led cohort must generate 1,200 paid subscription starts within 60 days. You have to weigh creator trust, channel reporting, and a budget choice that cannot be quietly reversed.
Connect creator ads to follows before the creative refresh
New installs are leaving without following the writer who brought them into the app. You have to weigh a more tailored landing path against clean attribution across the campaign.
Surface setup barriers without handing the roadmap to a model
Creator feedback about publication setup is arriving faster than PMs can reconcile it into recurring problems. You must weigh faster synthesis against the evidence PMs need to trust before acting.
Launch a health view so editors stop rebuilding revenue by hand
Growing publications are rebuilding subscriber and earnings views by hand because they cannot see momentum across their bylines. You have to weigh a clear next action against the risk of oversimplifying a publisher’s business.
Protect renewals while tax charges become the record
Affected subscribers are cancelling after higher renewal charges, while tax records must remain correct. You must weigh a clearer renewal experience against the risk of changing a collection flow that feeds remittance.
Turn imported audiences into first posts before momentum fades
Only 34% of creators who import an audience publish within seven days. You have to weigh faster setup against the guidance that gets a creator through their first blank draft.